David Letterman was once hailed as the king of late-night TV, but in today’s cultural climate, many of his past interviews are being reexamined—especially those with female guests. One that continues to resurface is his 2006 interview with Jennifer Aniston, promoting The Break-Up. Dressed in black shorts and a blouse, Aniston was poised and professional. But instead of focusing on her film, Letterman fixated on her appearance. “That’s a tremendous outfit,” he said.

“You can only wear that if you have lovely, well-shaped, muscular, lengthy legs.” Aniston laughed awkwardly, trying to move on, but Letterman continued, commenting again on her legs and even saying, “I hope somebody is TiVoing this because I can’t stop looking at this shot.” The exchange was uncomfortable then—and cringeworthy now.