Caleb recalls a photo he once found hidden in their attic—of a woman with a baby and a scar identical to Michelle’s. William had explained it away back then, but now Caleb suspects something darker. To find answers, Caleb devises a plan with Michelle. She pretends to be a door-to-door salesperson and visits William,who is visibly shaken. He notices her scar—and the way she instinctively knows details about the house she shouldn’t. Later that night, William sneaks into Michelle’s home, knife in hand, and stabs the figure in her bed—only to discover it’s a dummy. Police burst in and arrest him. It was a trap, set up by Caleb and the authorities. Under interrogation, William confesses: 28 years ago,

Jennifer (Caleb’s real mother) found out about his affair with his secretary, Olivia. She threatened divorce. Afraid of scandal and losing his wealth, William pushed her off a cliff during a picnic. Believing she died, he raised Caleb with Olivia and faked Jennifer’s grave. But Jennifer survived, lost her memory, and lived a hard life—until fate led her back to her son.